Tues - Fri: 10am - 6pm & Sat - Mon: Closed

The Ultimate Guide To Making Homemade Butter

December 10, 2020 0 Comments

The Ultimate Guide To Making Homemade Butter

Do you remember those long hours plunging that ol’ butter churn up and down to help out grandma get her butter ready for her Sunday supper?

Me neither

Butter is magical though, isn’t it? How can a spreadable delicious substance that can only be best described as buttery come from milk, a liquid?

Milk, from a state of matter perspective, is sort of deceptive. It is comprised of fat globules (solids) and of milk which is a liquid. When REAL milk is left to its own devices and is allowed to sit in time out for a minute (a least overnight) it will separate.

As you have probably heard the cream does RISE to the TOP. The cream is where butter starts. Even though it looks like it has fully segregated itself from the lowly milk on the bottom, there are still milk molecules hanging out suspended inside the cream.

The layer of cream that can be skimmed and collected. This is where they got the term “skim” milk.

Little known fact: Often times “skim” milk is fed to the piggies on small farms to fatten them up.

Now folks, please tell me why oh why have diet trends and doctors alike been preaching a diet of low-fat milk only, when for ages it’s been used to get a hog to market weight?

When you start shaking things up….things get INTERESTING.

The fat molecules get all riled up and start getting clumped together for security. After all this turmoil, it gets pretty clickish and the fats stick with the fats and the milk liquids to the milk liquids. (That sneaky milk is still in there though. Don’t let it fool you now.)

Did you know that commercial butter makers often add water to their butter to dilute it to the legal minimum fat content of 80% in the US?!?

This is one reason I feel it’s important to take the power of making our own food choices back into our own hands. Food is not what it says it is anymore. Unless we know our farmer and our food source, how can we really know what we are eating?

So let’s get that cream and start making butter shall we?


Step 1: Skim the Cream

Real that has not been skimmed will have the cream that rises to the top if left still overnight. There are several ways to collect the cream from the top. Some are easier or require more equipment than others.

  • The easiest way is to ask your farmer for some cream.
  • Pour your cream off the top after it has settled. This can lead to a more inconsistent cream amount but it works.
  • Use a turkey baster. Siphon off the cream from the top with the bulbed type turkey baster. Just make sure you are able to properly clean your tool later.
  • A drink dispenser with a spout at the bottom will work as long as you are able to see where the milk stops and cream begins. When you get down to the cream just switch containers. 

Step 2: Get to Shaking!

Pour the desired amount of heavy cream into your Kitchen Aid, or another method of agitation, and turn to medium speed.
There are several methods you can use here to agitate your cream. Before we got our official butter churn, my method choice was the Kitchen Aid with the whisk attachment.

Different Ways of Making Homemade Butter:

  1. Hand-Shaken - Put your heavy cream in a mason jar with the lid on tight and start shaking. This method takes the longest 
  2. Food Processor - This can be the fastest. If you have a traditional food processor, you will be able to push the “high” button and walk away. Unlike with handshaking though, it is not a ball and a liquid fully separated. You’ll need to take a mesh strainer and separate the liquid from the butter.
  3. Kitchen Aid Mixer - I am a HUGE fan of the kitchen aid mixer. It’s an essential part of a well-appointed foodie kitchen. Set on medium high and if you have a splash shield… use it! Otherwise, a dishcloth works just fine. Make sure to stop it a few times, and scrape the butter liquid down into the bowl.
  4. Butter Churner - I am very proud to have our 3-gallon, 1950’s butter churn we purchased from our “Dairy God-Parents”. But, this really isn’t necessary if you are just getting started or making a small batch. 

Step 3: Wait…. Keep mixing, and mixing, THEN mix a little more

Whatever your preferred method of agitating your butter is, this part will feel the most frustrating because it takes so long.

Step 4: Separation is Natural

Watch for separation and solidification. The solids will start to separate and have a grainy appearance. Wait for just a little longer until the "grains" become bigger and more clumped together.

Step 5: Strain

Pour into a bowl and strain the butter solids from the buttermilk. You can use a strainer but I just like to use my hands and a bowl because it seems to always get caught in the mesh.

This is the part where you need to be most concerned about temperature. If the butter has gotten warm it will be sticky. It will stick to everything else BUT what you need it too when it is too warm. 

Step 6: Rinse the Butter

* This is the most important part and most overlooked. If buttermilk or excess water is left inside it will cause your hard earned butter to go rancid.

Use VERY cold water to rinse your butter. Rinse 2-4 times or until the water runs almost clear.

You can rinse it by patting the granules together under cold water. Knead it as though you are kneading some dough. 

When you feel you have gotten all the liquids out you can salt your butter to taste. I am usually working with a pound or two and start with a teaspoon. Work your butter until it is thoroughly incorporated. 

Salting your butter can ensure a better shelf life if you decide to keep some out on the counter. It also seems to encourage the water molecules to head on out. 

Unlike cream, butter stores very well in the freezer. Store in the freezer in a well-sealed container for up to a year. 

The first draw of liquid is your "buttermilk". It will not behave the same way regular buttermilk will in recipes though unless you 1) cultured your cream to make cultured butter OR 2) Leave the buttermilk out with a cloth or half sealed lid overnight. 

So there you have it! You have butter! 
Now your inner farm girl can sleep well knowing you can do it! 

Are you curious about trying REAL milk?

Come by the FARM STORE to get some for your own yogurt making.

Also in Blog

Cooking Up Love: Try This Chocolatey Delight for Valentine's Day!
Cooking Up Love: Try This Chocolatey Delight for Valentine's Day!

January 26, 2024 0 Comments

Continue Reading

News from Cottonwood Marketplace

February 22, 2023 0 Comments

Continue Reading

Why is Pasture Raised Turkey More Expensive?
Why is Pasture Raised Turkey More Expensive?

July 12, 2022 0 Comments

You may like the idea of buying local and having a pasture raised bird for your Thanksgiving but then you see the price tag and are immediately taken back. Let me show you some of the TRUE costs of farming. 

Continue Reading